Lost Media: Linguistics Rock!—The SpecGram Media Elves™ SpecGram Vol CXCV, No 3 Contents The Secret Life of Agentives—Maxwell Smart, B.A. and “Susan” “Hilton”, 99 Ph.D.s

The Evocative Case:
New Data from Nahuatlepec de Santiago Ramón y Cajal

Adam Baker

This brief article presents data from Nahuatlepec de Santiago Ramón y Cajal, with a focus on the evocative case, which has not previously been described in the literature. The evocative case is used in narrative and hortatory texts to evoke an emotional response from the listener. This will be most easily seen from the free translations below.

Data

The language has a surface SOV word order, and basic nominative-accusative case marking, as seen below.

(1)
jast-na
boy-NOM
kutme-s-ta
mother-3POSS-ACC
ord
see.PST
“The boy saw his mother.”

The evocative case marker can replace any other case marker in the language, which motivates its analysis as a case marker as opposed to some other suffix. The next example is parallel to (1), but with the direct object marked with the evocative case.

(2)
jast-na
boy-NOM
kutme-s-ma
mother-3POSS-EVOC
ord
see.PST
“The boy saw the very origin of his being, that mysterious Other without whom he would have no being, whose origin he could not describe, whose sexuality was at once taboo and the origin of his existence..”

As the translation above indicates, use of the evocative case replaces the accusative in a transitive sentence. In intransitive sentences, however, only the nominative can be replaced with an evocative case marker.

(3)
cymp-na
cow-NOM
werq-xe
field-LOC
kɪl
walk
“The cow walks in the field.”

(4)
cymp-ma
cow-EVOC
werq-xe
field-LOC
kɪl
walk
“The magnificent beast, representing in itself mankind’s mastery over nature, while simultaneously bearing the strength to destroy the life of any particular man, source of food through both the gentle massage of the teat and the cruel blow of the knife, walks in the field.”

Consistently with the ergative pattern illustrated above, non-core arguments cannot receive evocative case. The ungrammaticality of example (6) shows an attempt at promoting the locative to evocative case.

(5)
kutme-na
mother-NOM
uy-xe
house-LOC
θɬaq-ts
work-PRES
“The mother works in the house.”

(6)
*kutme-na
mother-NOM
uy-ma
house-EVOC
θɬaq-ts
work-PRES
“The mother works in the bosom of the family, hearth and home, that luminous zone where first steps and last breaths are taken, where we first learn to love and, all too often, to hate.”

Moreover, only one argument can be promoted to evocative position. Examples such as the following, where both nominative and accusative NPs receive the evocative case are judged ungrammaticalthe specific term used was [ˈzʌt͜sɯzi] ‘trying too hard’.

(7)
*kutme-ma
mother-EVOC
cymp-ma
cow-EVOC
ord-ts
see-PRES
“The family matriarch, sustainer of infants and menfolk, sees the beast of burden who is yet also mother, those two alike whom necessity demands that they sustain others even as they sustain themselves.”

Directions for further research

The sample of data offered here is a small portion of what is to be found in my records. Future publications will explore the fascinating morphosyntactic research that was only possible through my close collaboration with the last remaining speaker of Nahuatlepec de Santiago Ramón y Cajal, who has unfortunately recently passed away. Although the data access restrictions he insisted upon mean that the notebooks and recordings can never be published in full, my informant gave explicit permission for me to publish as much language data as I wished in journal articles, of which I anticipate publishing many.

Lost Media: Linguistics Rock!The SpecGram Media Elves™
The Secret Life of AgentivesMaxwell Smart, B.A. and “Susan” “Hilton”, 99 Ph.D.s
SpecGram Vol CXCV, No 3 Contents